Hertzberg's Motivation Theory

Motivational Theory (Hertzberg) by Alec McPhedran

Herzberg's Motivational Theory, also known as the Two-Factor Theory, is a psychological theory of motivation in the workplace. Developed by Frederick Herzberg in the 1950s, it distinguishes between two types of factors that influence people motivation and satisfaction: hygiene factors and motivators.
 
Hygiene Factors
Hygiene factors, also known as extrinsic factors, do not lead to higher motivation or job satisfaction, but their absence can cause dissatisfaction. These factors are related to the job environment and include: 
Company Policies: Clear, fair, and well-communicated company policies. 
Supervision: The quality of supervision and management. 
Working Conditions: Physical working environment, including safety, comfort, and cleanliness. 
Salary: Pay and benefits. 
Interpersonal Relations: Relationships with supervisors, peers, and subordinates. 
Job Security: Stability and security of employment.
 
Motivators
Motivators, or intrinsic factors, are related to the nature of the work itself and can lead to higher motivation and job satisfaction when present. These factors include:

•  Achievement: Sense of accomplishment and success in one's work.
• Recognition: Acknowledgment and appreciation for one's efforts and contributions.
• Work Itself: The nature of the work and the tasks involved.
• Responsibility: Having control over one's work and being given significant responsibilities.
• Advancement: Opportunities for career growth and promotion.
• Personal Growth: Opportunities for personal and professional development.

 
Key Points of the Motivational Theory
1. Dual Continuum
Herzberg's theory posits that job satisfaction and dissatisfaction are not opposite ends of the same continuum. Instead, they are influenced by different sets of factors. Improving hygiene factors can reduce dissatisfaction, but it won't necessarily increase satisfaction. Conversely, enhancing motivators can increase satisfaction but won't necessarily reduce dissatisfaction if hygiene factors are lacking.
 
2. Implications for Management
To motivate employees effectively, managers should focus on both sets of factors. They should ensure that hygiene factors are adequately addressed to prevent dissatisfaction and also work on enhancing motivators to drive satisfaction and motivation.
 
Practical Applications

• Job Enrichment: Designing jobs that include greater responsibility, recognition, and opportunities for personal growth.
• Performance Management: Providing regular feedback, recognition, and opportunities for achievement.
• Work Environment: Creating a positive and supportive work environment with fair policies, good working conditions, and effective supervision.

 
In summary, Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory provides a framework for understanding what drives employee motivation and satisfaction, emphasizing the importance of addressing both hygiene factors and motivators in the workplace.
 
 
So how do I use Motivational Factors as a manager?
 
Using Herzberg's Motivational Theory in the workplace involves addressing both hygiene factors and motivators to create an environment where employees can be both satisfied and motivated. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to apply this theory:
 
1. Assess the Current Work Environment

• Conduct Surveys and Interviews: Gather feedback from employees about their job satisfaction and areas of dissatisfaction.
• Identify Hygiene Factors: Determine whether employees are dissatisfied due to poor hygiene factors such as company policies, supervision, working conditions, salary, interpersonal relations, or job security.
• Identify Motivators: Understand what factors currently contribute to job satisfaction and motivation, such as achievement, recognition, the nature of the work, responsibility, advancement, and personal growth.

 
2. Address Hygiene Factors
Ensure that basic needs and workplace conditions are met to prevent dissatisfaction:

• Improve Company Policies: Review and update company policies to ensure they are fair, clear, and well-communicated.
• Enhance Supervision: Train managers and supervisors to provide effective, supportive, and fair supervision.
• Optimize Working Conditions: Ensure the physical work environment is safe, comfortable, and conducive to productivity.
• Review Compensation: Ensure that pay and benefits are competitive and fair.
• Foster Positive Interpersonal Relations: Promote a culture of respect and collaboration among employees.
• Ensure Job Security: Provide clear communication about job stability and future prospects.

 
3. Enhance Motivators
Create conditions that foster job satisfaction and intrinsic motivation:

• Provide Opportunities for Achievement: Set challenging but attainable goals for employees and acknowledge their accomplishments.
• Recognize Contributions: Implement regular and meaningful recognition programs to appreciate employees’ efforts and successes.
• Enrich Job Content: Design jobs that are interesting, engaging, and provide a sense of purpose.
• Increase Responsibility: Delegate meaningful responsibilities and give employees more control over their work.
• Support Career Advancement: Create clear career paths and provide opportunities for promotions and role advancements.
• Facilitate Personal Growth: Offer training, professional development programs, and learning opportunities to help employees grow and develop new skills.

 
4. Monitor and Adjust

• Regular Feedback: Continuously seek feedback from employees about their job satisfaction and the effectiveness of implemented changes.
• Continuous Improvement: Regularly review and adjust policies, practices, and programs based on feedback and changing needs.

 
Using Motivational Theory Example
 An organization notices that employee turnover is high and motivation levels are low.
 
Steps:
1. Assess the Situation: Conduct an employee survey to identify dissatisfaction areas. Results show that employees are unhappy with the outdated equipment (hygiene factor) and feel unappreciated (lack of motivators).

2. Address Hygiene Factors: Upgrade equipment and tools to improve working conditions.

3. Enhance Motivators: Implement an employee recognition program and provide regular feedback and opportunities for career development.

4. Monitor and Adjust: After a few months, conduct follow-up surveys to evaluate the impact of these changes and make necessary adjustments.
 
By systematically addressing both hygiene factors and motivators, managers can create a work environment that not only prevents dissatisfaction but also actively promotes employee motivation and satisfaction.
 
 
What are the problems with Herzberg Motivational Theory?
 
While Herzberg's Motivational Theory offers valuable insights into employee motivation and job satisfaction, it is not without its criticisms and potential limitations. Here are some of the main issues or negatives associated with the theory:
 
1. Simplification of Complex Motivations
Herzberg’s theory simplifies the complexity of human motivation by categorizing factors strictly into hygiene and motivators. In reality, the distinction between these two categories may not be as clear-cut. Some factors can act as both motivators and hygiene factors depending on the context and individual preferences.
 
2. Overemphasis on Job Content
The theory emphasizes job content (motivators) over other potential sources of motivation, such as external rewards or social factors. It may overlook the importance of intrinsic motivation and personal differences in what individuals find motivating.
 
3. Methodological Criticisms
Herzberg’s original research methodology, which involved critical incident interviews, has been criticized for potential biases. Participants may have a tendency to attribute their successes to internal factors (achievement, responsibility) and their failures to external factors (company policies, working conditions).
 
4. Limited Applicability Across Cultures and Industries
The theory was developed based on studies of American workers in the 1950s and may not be universally applicable. Cultural differences can significantly impact what employees find motivating or dissatisfying. Moreover, the theory may not fully apply to all industries or job types, especially those where intrinsic job factors are less prominent.
 
5. Ignoring Individual Differences
Herzberg's theory assumes a general applicability to all employees, but individual differences in personality, values, and life circumstances can significantly influence what motivates a person. One-size-fits-all approaches based on the theory may not be effective for everyone.
 
6. Static Nature of the Theory
The theory does not account for changes in employee motivation over time. What motivates or dissatisfies an employee can change due to various factors such as career stage, personal life changes, or shifts in organizational culture.
 
7. Focus on Satisfaction Rather Than Performance
While Herzberg's theory focuses on job satisfaction and dissatisfaction, it does not directly address the link between these factors and actual job performance. Employees might be satisfied but not necessarily productive or high-performing.
 
8. Lack of Consideration for External Factors
The theory primarily focuses on internal job factors and does not consider external influences such as economic conditions, labour market trends, or societal changes that can impact employee motivation and satisfaction.
 
9. Challenges in Practical Implementation
Implementing changes based on Herzberg’s theory can be challenging. Addressing hygiene factors requires substantial investment and resources, and enriching job roles to enhance motivators can be complex and may not always align with organizational needs or structures.
 
Despite these criticisms, Herzberg’s Motivational Theory remains a useful tool for understanding some of the key factors that influence employee motivation and satisfaction. Managers should consider it as one of many frameworks and combine it with other motivational theories and practical insights to create a more comprehensive approach to managing and motivating employees.
 
Alec McPhedran Chtd Fellow CIPD, Chtd Mngr CMI, MCMI  is a recognised creative sector coach and mentor. He specialises in one to one talent coaching, facilitated learning and team development. For further information, visit www.mcphedran.co.uk.

Copyright © Alec McPhedran 2024